Thread:Fairingrey/@comment-5924050-20150312205902/@comment-24802125-20150313031917

Renwit.... No. Let me repeat.

No. no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no...

and finally, NO.

That's the tl;dr. Here's the long version.

The reason why the VC wiki uses that is because it isn't inherently said in the game what artist it is. Thus, that's an extraeneous feature. VC never tells you who illustrates which unit, so the wiki does its' best to categorize it, and it sometimes can be wrong. Which is why it has those, to the helpful benefit of those contributors who actually go out on a leg and do that.

On the other hand, the game here, Ishtaria, actually tells you the CV actor for each unit. The general guideline, and almost to a policy, is to aim for as accurate of a representation as the unit actually is in the game. That is, whatever information is provided is provided here as accurately as possible, save for the fact we have to fix some of their typos. Including extraneous "guessing" information isn't helpful, and may almost serve to confuse some readers assuming that they don't know what kind of placeholder CV A, or CV B, or CV C is supposed to be.

This even applies to Unreleased units. Whatever unreleased units there are, are detailed as accurately as they can be with knowledge of those units in the JP server. We do that kind of preparation to help easily edit the page when the unit is finally released, and also to give people a heads up on what kind of units are coming to the Ishtaria we play next. However, as much as it might be a guessing game, how to romanize the names and how to detail the skills, we still try to aim for an accurate representation of the content that might be in store for us from another game.

We don't want to do that. To jumble up the information is something I'd rather not do, especially when it's a suggestion coming from someone that has pushed for some requests and yet hasn't done their legwork to help the features along. For one example, Kimlasca has put in a lot more work to fill out the quest list stuff and provide more helpful input whereas you haven't, even though you being the one who requested for that change.

It's not that I'm judging you as a contributor since you are still a very nice and helpful person, but a suggestion isn't an effort, and I'd like to make a big distinction for that. If I don't think it's needed and nobody else provides further reasons to, I won't put it in. Especially when it conflicts with the wiki's interests, to portray information as accurately as it can.

You, however, are welcome to edit your own sandbox for organizational purposes, in the hopes that when those units finally do get their CV's filled in you may be able to fill out the information much faster, but the information is to limited to your own and whoever you can source for "voice clips". I don't think I can allow an actual discussion about how Leraju's voice sounds like it's from CV A or how Lamashtu's voice sounds like it's from CV B because that isn't accurate information. And there are tons of VA's we don't know about. That's why I don't like just 'estimating'.